You are here: Home > Blogging

Electric Cars

I have an opinion piece in the Canberra Times today on the benefits of electric cars.

Driving a clean, green future, Canberra Times, 3 April 2012

Last month another charge spot was added to Canberra’s growing charge network. In addition to their charge locations at the Belconnen Markets, National Convention Centre, and Crowne Plaza, Better Place opened a new spot at the Novotel Hotel on Northbourne Avenue. Across the ACT there are now 14 charge spot locations.

Electric cars have the potential to benefit Australia’s economy, health and environment. With global oil prices steadily creeping upwards (due to growing demand in China and other emerging economies), average Australians are now paying over $1.40 per litre for unleaded petrol.

Petrol-consuming passenger vehicles account for nearly half of Australia’s liquid fuel consumption. Hybrid and electric cars offer the chance to reduce our dependence on the global oil market.

Using current national electricity generation methods, producing electricity for travel in hybrid and electric cars releases less greenhouse gas emissions than combustion in petrol cars. This is true even if the electricity is produced using ‘dirty’ technology. For example, an electric car powered by electricity from a coal fired power station emits less greenhouse gas than a petrol car.

If the electricity comes from renewables, we can do even better. In 2010, Australia generated 15,000 gigawatt hours of renewable energy, sufficient to supply a fleet of five million electric cars without any ‘well to wheel’ greenhouse gas emissions. The Australian government is committed to generating 20 per cent of Australia’s electricity from renewable sources by 2020, which equates to 45,000 gigawatt hours of renewable energy annually. That’s enough to supply an entire national electric car fleet with zero greenhouse gas emissions.

The health benefits of electric cars are also significant. Unlike petrol vehicles, electric cars have no tailpipe emissions, only pre-combustion emissions. Unlike those from petrol vehicles, these include virtually no carbon monoxide, hydrocarbons or particulate matter emissions and only a quarter of the nitrogen oxides released by petrol vehicles. The total reduction of air pollutants in electric vehicles’ emissions compared to petrol vehicles’ emissions ranges between 10 and 20 grams per kilometre.

Electric vehicles also require less maintenance, as they have 70 per cent fewer moving and consumable parts. This is estimated to halve maintenance costs over a ten year period.

Research from RMIT finds that electric cars require 20 per cent less lifecycle energy and associated greenhouse gas emissions than petrol vehicles. Indeed, because they’re so cheap to run and maintain, the only risk that I can see being posed by electric cars is that they could encourage more people to commute by car, thereby increasing traffic congestion.

One of the great advantages of electric cars comes because the wholesale cost of electricity varies dramatically over the course of a day. Electric cars can take advantage of this by charging when electricity is cheapest (and putting power back into the grid when it is most expensive). This minimises the impact of electric cars on the energy infrastructure and allows them to collect and store up to seven kilowatts of energy, generated in times of low electricity demand, which would otherwise be wasted. A car can then later return any surplus energy to the grid in periods of high demand to power the community or other cars that require immediate charging, greatly reducing the demand for additional energy generation.

By capturing, saving and returning excess energy to the grid, electric cars are a neat complement to energy production sources like wind generation. On one estimate, each electric car could enable the retention of 43 megawatt hours of renewable wind energy annually. Because each electric vehicle would require only 2.7 megawatt hours of electricity to recharge over a year, this means that each car is effectively saving 40 megawatt hours of energy that would otherwise be lost. This means that a fleet of one million electric vehicles would allow us to achieve the 45,000 gigawatt hours of renewable energy required by the national Renewable Energy Target.

With the charging network now in operation, having more electric cars in Canberra offers us an opportunity to save money, increase the health of our community, and decrease car maintenance costs. By reducing Australia’s greenhouse gas emissions, we have the opportunity to charge towards a new cleaner, healthier and more sustainable future. Now that’s the kind of change we’re driving towards.

Andrew Leigh is the Federal Member for Fraser, and his website is www.andrewleigh.com.

8 Comments

  1. Gavin H says:

    There are a number of issues with electric cars but the main issue at this time is is their upfront costs ~$48,000 to $60,000 and with the equivalent Toyota Yaris selling for $18,000(5.7l/100km) even at even $2 per litre is is equivalent to traveling 256,000 km prior to reaching break even with just the purchase of the electric car.

    Now throw the new Prius C into the mix at $24k and 3.8l/100 km the electric car is a long way off being viable to the average householder.

    Electric cars are only forecast to account for only 1 to 2 per cent of sales until 2015 (10,000/year) rising to 20% by 2020 (100,000/year). Given that only 49 electric cars sold in 2011 (0.0049%). I think this is very optimistic given that today Chevy announced that its factory shutdown for the Volt would be extended by another week.

    The Prius does illustrate what can happen though, as 15 years after it first rolled off the assembly line its finally becoming affordable. Perhaps we can hope the cycle time for electric vehicles to become affordable will be quicker, because I wouldn’t mind my next car (or perhaps the one after being an electric car).

    Petrol at $5 per litre would be a game changer though, perhaps Andrew would like to talk about it in context of the Transport Energy Futures report, which predicts oil production falling of a cliff in 2017.

    http://www.manicore.com/fichiers/Australian_Govt_Oil_supply_trends.pdf

    I would be interested to hear from Andrew regarding any government modelling of oil prices in 2020 or when he think oil prices will start to bite?

    • Tremendous article: what is so special here is his penultimate paragraph explaining how by storing otherwise lost renewable power, EVs can actually be net savers of energy rather than users. This is rather hard to get one’s head around.

      People in Israel think I’m a bit nuts when I say that the rate EV car provider Better Place are paying for their electricity is certainly much lower than the domestic user rate. I even believe it could be zero or negative some day because when the capacity to store energy in their subscribers cars is priced, it becomes worth more than the electricity itself!

  2. Simon says:

    The problem with cars, electric or otherwise, isn’t their fuel efficiency but their space efficiency. They require so much space, both for the roads on which they travel, and for their storage during the 95% of the time that they lie idle, that cities become stretched out into endless sprawl, forcing everybody, whether or not they drive, to travel much further than they otherwise would to access their daily needs.

    • Hi Simon,

      I share your thoughts. There is always a trade of between public and private transport. In many cases there are optimum configurations, but not always.

      But this are 2 different discussions: “How to increase public transport” AND “How to make private transport greener”. Both should be forced at the same time, without excluding the other.

      We have discussed about this on our weekly #EVChat, an online chat about electric cars and green transport. Step by next Monday at 20:00 GTM.

      bye

      Olmo

  3. solar gadgets says:

    Funny that I didn’t see any quotes from the AMA, HHS, FDA or CDC!

  4. [...] other emerging economies), average Australians are now paying … … Read this article: Andrew Leigh » Blog Archive » Electric Cars ← Hyundai and Magna form Electric Car Battery JV | Electric Vehicle [...]

  5. Simon says:

    Well, it’s not exactly a public vs private transport issue. If you want to make “private transport greener” then ditch the car and cycle or walk.

    The issue is the interaction between transport policy and land use.

  6. Peggy says:

    One thing seldom mentioned re EVs is the batteries, their life and cost of replacement. I did some research on this and found that the cost of replacing batteries after about 3 years ( average ) was half the cost of a new EV.
    One model cost $32,000 and the cost of battery replacement is $15,000. If the batteries only last 3 years on average, that’s $5,000 a year without the added cost of the electricity to recharge.